One of the unique offerings of Netflix this past month was the movie that talked about two popes, entitled, "The Two Popes". It shows the contrast between the current Pope, Pope Francis and the previous one, Pope Emeritus Benedict XVI. Now, I'll leave this note here before I proceed with my reflection that most of what appears in the movie is based on 100% fiction. Pope Benedict, I believe is portrayed poorly. It shows the common trope of "conservatives are bad and progressives are good" while not addressing the in-between as much as I would have hoped.
That said, I liked how the movie made me reflect on the actual two popes. I'm at an age where I remember both of them being elected. I remember what both of them brought to the table as I noticed it in my life as a Catholic.
A line was said by Benedict in the film, "God always corrects one pope by presenting the world with another Pope. I'd like to see my correction." This line struck me as it wasn't the first time I had heard it. As a practicing Catholic, I love reading about how the popes in the past had addressed certain issues and how each pope is always different. They always bring different things to the table but always within the bounds of truth.
I remember the under Benedict XVI, a new translation of the mass became normal. The idea was to avoid translations of translations when celebrating the mass. The mass would be translated directly from Latin into the language being used. It was difficult at first but with this slight change came with it a huge appreciation for the faith I never knew was there.
Lines like, "And with your spirit," instead of "And also with you," have helped me see more clearly some truths that were previously not seen with the other translation. There are many more of these minor tweaks to the language which is said to encapsulate the meaning of the lines much better than the older translations. This is what I appreciate the most from Benedict XVI's papacy, which I don't think Pope Francis or Pope John Paul II would have even thought of addressing.
Contrast that to today, Pope Francis' papacy stresses the idea of welcoming more people to be in communion with the church. The single most important pronouncement, I believe, would be that all priests now have the authority to absolve the grievous sin of abortion. Most people do not know this but to stress how abhorrent abortion is to the church, she has a rule that abortion can only be forgiven when confessed to a bishop. In fact, the procedure when anyone confesses abortion to a priest who didn't have the authority to forgive it was to stop the confession and refer them directly to the bishop or to another priest who did have that authority.
The main goal of the church then was to stress the evil that was parading itself as a woman's right. Truly, it's much more difficult to be forgiven for abortion than for murder. Pope Francis, however, granted all priests the authority to forgive even abortions. This was done to stress the availability of God's love to the world. This move, I believe, is one that Pope Benedict would not have done as I think he wishes to stress the evil more than stress the power of God's mercy.
In fact, many conservative Catholics complained that this might be taken by the world as the church saying that abortion is not that grave a sin as it can be much more easily forgiven. I was one of those. But Pope Francis never said that abortion is any less grave now than before. He simply wishes to put more stress on the love of God for His children.
I find it very interesting to see what each pope brings to the table. Neither pope ever changed church doctrine. Then simply lead or nudge the church is the direction which is the most appropriate for their time. This is not to say that each pope is perfect. Far from it. But it's these imperfect popes we have that make our Church a great one.



